Historical accuracy is important
It has come to the attention of the publishers of the Greene County Democrat
that the Greene County Historical Society of Alabama plans to give its Distinguished Service Award to Judge J. Dennis Herndon.
Herndon is deceased and was a founder of the Greene County Historical Society, but there are some historical facts that suggest that his contributions to Greene County and adjoining counties were not worthy to be considered as “distinguished service” to a multi-racial democratic society, which most of us are trying to build.
Judge Herndon was the official responsible for deliberately leaving the names of Black officials, running with the National Democratic Party of Alabama (NDPA) off the ballot in 1966 and again in 1968. The NDPA had to challenge him in court and take the case to the U.S. Supreme Court to secure a special election on July 29, 1969, which led to the election of a majority Black County Commission and School Board. The Supreme Court of the United States held Circuit Judge J. Dennis Herndon in contempt for his actions to prevent Black people, in a majority Black County, from exercising their democratic right to vote for candidates of their own choosing.
Another example of Circuit Judge Herndon’s inequitable administration of justice was his treatment of the Panola Land Buying Association (PLBA), when he blocked their efforts to purchase 1,164 acres of land in Sumter County for three years from 1967 to 1970. The 40 members families of the PLBA were tenant farmers evicted from plantations in north Sumter County for engaging in civil rights activities. They just wanted some land to continue farming and build housing. The PLBA and their supporters, worked together with a white merchant in Gainesville, who had lost three tracts of land in a foreclosure, to exercise his redemption rights, under Alabama law to recover the land.
Every time the PLBA went into Judge Herndon’s court for three years he postponed and blocked a decision in their case. The lawyers for PLBA had to remove the case to Federal Court in Birmingham to get a judgement that adjudicated the redemption in their favor and allowed them to purchase the land. The Federation of Southern Cooperatives assisted the PLBA in purchasing, financing and paying for the land, a portion of which is now the organization’s Rural Training and Research Center.
We raise these concerns because we feel the Greene County Historical Society needs to appreciate the full evaluation of Judge Herndon and other white people’s past actions before giving them awards. We hope our raising these concerns will lead to a more open and truthful dialogue between Black and White people in Greene County on how to work together for a joint future with truth and justice for all.
CORRECTION
Letter to the Editor
Dear Editors
Having read your editorial regarding the late Dennis Herndon and your calling for historical accuracy please check your facts regarding who served at the 17th Circuit Court Judge during the time frame of your Editorial content regarding PLBA.
It was in fact, Emmett Hildreth, who was appointed by Alabama Governor Chauncey Sparks in 1943 to serve as Circuit Court Judge for the 17th Judicial District comprising of the counties of Greene, Marengo, and Sumter. Hildreth was subsequently elected to the position and was re-elected such that he served in the position for thirty years until his death in 1973.
Dennis Herndon served as the Probate Judge of Greene County from 1959-1971.
Sharon S. Trammell
Editor
Greene County Independent
Editors Note: We stand corrected. We regret our error; however we understand that both
Judge Herndon and Judge Hildreth used the Alabama judicial system in a racist and exclusionary manner toward Black people, during the period prior to 1970.
















